The lowest credible published average for Pennsylvania homeowners insurance is the NAIC's $1,120 a year for an HO-3 policy — measured on 2022 data, before three years of approved statewide increases. Profile studies published in 2026 land between roughly $1,200 and $2,200 for a standard home. Here's what each number measures, why they differ, and what actually sets the price of your policy.
How much is homeowners insurance in PA?
- Published averages for homeowners insurance in Pennsylvania start at $1,120 a year — the NAIC's average HO-3 premium (2022 data) — with 2026 profile studies running roughly $1,200 to $2,200 for a standard home.
- Pennsylvania runs well below the national average. The same NAIC data put the U.S. average HO-3 premium at $1,569, ranking Pennsylvania 39th of 51 jurisdictions.
- Today's number is higher than the NAIC's. Pennsylvania regulators approved homeowners increases averaging 13.6% in 2024, 6.3% in 2025 and about 1.8% through July 2026, per S&P Global Market Intelligence.
- Your dwelling limit drives the price. Premiums scale with the cost to rebuild — one 2026 profile study priced a $600,000 dwelling at more than twice its $200,000 profile.
- Flood and mine subsidence are separate. Neither is in a standard homeowners policy; mine subsidence coverage through the state program costs roughly 27 cents per $1,000 of coverage.
- The only number that's yours is a quote. Call or text the Brandon Petroziello Agency at (610) 935-9458 — we'll price your actual house at its real rebuild cost.
Key facts: PA homeowners insurance costs (2026)
| PA average HO-3 premium | $1,120 per year (2022 data — lowest credible published average) | NAIC via Insurance Information Institute |
| U.S. average HO-3 premium | $1,569 — Pennsylvania ranks 39th of 51 | NAIC via Insurance Information Institute |
| Approved PA increase, 2024 | Averaged 13.6% | S&P Global Market Intelligence, 2026 |
| Approved PA increase, 2025 | Averaged 6.3% | S&P Global Market Intelligence, 2026 |
| Approved PA increase, 2026 | About 1.8% through July | S&P Global Market Intelligence, 2026 |
| 2026 profile estimates | Roughly $1,200–$2,200/yr for a standard home | Published 2026 profile studies |
| Mine subsidence insurance | About 27¢ per $1,000 of coverage (~$44/yr on $160,000) | PA DEP (as of September 2026) |
| Flood insurance | Excluded from homeowners; separate NFIP or private policy | FEMA / NFIP (2026) |
Every site answering this question prints a different number, and most present it as if it were your price. Here's the honest version from a licensed Pennsylvania agency: the lowest credible published average is the NAIC's $1,120 a year for an HO-3 homeowners policy — real premiums, averaged statewide, but measured on 2022 data. Profile studies published in 2026 run higher because they price a specific hypothetical house with today's rates. Neither is a quote. This guide lays out each figure with its source and its method, walks through what actually sets a Pennsylvania homeowners premium — the same structure behind our Pennsylvania home insurance page — and ends with the one number that describes your house.
What Do Pennsylvania Homeowners Pay on Average?
The short answer: The lowest credible published average is the NAIC's $1,120 a year for an HO-3 policy (2022 data) — about $93 a month — with 2026 profile studies landing roughly between $1,200 and $2,200.
Start with the most defensible number available. The National Association of Insurance Commissioners — the regulators' own association — collects actual written premiums from insurers, and its homeowners data, as tabulated by the Insurance Information Institute, puts Pennsylvania's average HO-3 premium at $1,120 per year for the 2022 data year. HO-3 is the standard form most owner-occupied homes carry.
Two points of context make that number useful. First, Pennsylvania is well below the national average — roughly 29% under the U.S. figure in the same data, largely because the state avoids the hurricane and wildfire exposure driving premiums elsewhere. Second, the number is old. NAIC homeowners data runs several years behind, and Pennsylvania insurers have filed substantial increases since 2022 — more on that below.
Profile studies published in 2026 fill in the present tense: for a standard Pennsylvania home, they land roughly between $1,200 and $2,200 a year, depending on the house each study models. If those two figures feel far apart, that gap is the next section.
One practical note on how you'll actually pay it. Most Pennsylvania homeowners with a mortgage never see a separate insurance bill: the lender collects one-twelfth of the annual premium with each mortgage payment and pays the insurer from escrow. That's convenient, but it also means renewal increases arrive as a higher mortgage payment months later — which is why reading the renewal itself matters.
In short: $1,120 is the documented statewide floor — the 2026 studies above it are pricing a specific house at today's rates.
Why Do Published Pennsylvania Home Insurance Averages Disagree?
The short answer: Each source prices a different house — the NAIC averages every real HO-3 policy on older data, while profile studies quote one hypothetical home at current rates — so their numbers have to differ.
Search for this and you'll meet a dozen “Pennsylvania averages.” None of them is lying. They measure different things:
Read as rivals, the numbers are confusing. Read as boundaries, they're a map. The NAIC figure tells you where Pennsylvania sits nationally. The profile studies tell you roughly what a mid-sized home costs today. And the spread between studies — which mostly comes from the dwelling limit each one assumes — tells you which input matters most.
A compliance note that's also a reader protection: every dollar figure on this page is an attributed published average, not a rate we're representing. The only figure that describes your house is a quote priced on it.
In short: the averages disagree because they must — and knowing why turns the disagreement into information.
What Has Changed Since the Published Data?
The short answer: Pennsylvania regulators approved homeowners increases averaging 13.6% in 2024, 6.3% in 2025 and about 1.8% through July 2026, and inflation-guard provisions raised dwelling limits along the way.
The NAIC's 2022 figure predates the hardest stretch of the homeowners market in years. Analysts at S&P Global Market Intelligence tally approved rate filings, and Pennsylvania's recent curve looks like this: 13.6% in 2024, 6.3% in 2025, and about 1.8% through July 2026. The pace is cooling sharply — but each year's increase compounds on the last.
Two other forces sit on top of the rate changes. Inflation guard — the automatic annual increase to your dwelling limit — has been raising the amount the rate applies to, because rebuilding costs climbed with materials and labor. And non-rate changes — higher minimum deductibles, percentage wind/hail deductibles and roof payout schedules — shifted cost onto homeowners without showing up in rate statistics at all.
That's why a homeowner comparing today's quote with the 2022 average will almost always see a higher number. We break the drivers down in detail in our guide to why Pennsylvania home insurance went up.
In short: the published floor is real, but three years of approved increases sit between it and 2026.
What Actually Sets Your Pennsylvania Home Insurance Price?
The short answer: Rebuild cost, roof, age and construction, location, deductible structure, claims history and discounts do most of the work — and several of them are decisions, not facts.
Under the averages, a Pennsylvania homeowners premium is assembled from a knowable list:
Rebuild cost
The dwelling limit — what it would cost to rebuild the house today — is the base the rate applies to. It's the single largest driver.
Roof age and type
The most scrutinized component in today's market. It affects the premium, the deductible structure and how a roof claim settles.
Age and construction
Pennsylvania has some of the country's oldest housing. Stone, plaster, slate and older systems all change rebuild cost and underwriting.
Location
Construction costs, weather exposure, fire protection and claim patterns by area. Philadelphia generally prices above rural Pennsylvania.
Deductible structure
The all-peril deductible plus any separate wind/hail or percentage deductible. A choice, not a fact.
Claims history
Recent claims — especially several small ones — commonly raise the price and cost claim-free credits.
Liability and endorsements
Higher liability limits, water backup, service lines and scheduled valuables each add cost — and close real gaps.
Discounts
Bundling, protective devices, new-roof credits, claim-free and paid-in-full options. Unclaimed credits are a silent overpayment.
Notice the pattern: the first four are facts about the house. The last four are decisions. Two neighbors with nearly identical homes can pay meaningfully different premiums because one made those decisions deliberately.
In short: the house sets the base; your deductible, coverage and discount decisions set the rest.
If the property is a condo unit or a rental, the math changes: see what condo insurance costs in Pennsylvania and what landlord insurance costs.
How Much Does the Dwelling Limit Change the Price?
The short answer: A lot — premiums scale with the rebuild cost you insure, and one 2026 profile study priced a $600,000 dwelling at more than twice its $200,000 profile.
If you remember one input from this page, make it this one. The dwelling limit — Coverage A — should equal what it would cost to rebuild your house at today's construction prices. The premium scales with it. Published 2026 profile studies show the effect clearly: one priced a $200,000 dwelling around $1,150 a year and a $600,000 dwelling around $2,570 — more than double.
Also worth knowing: rebuild cost isn't market value or purchase price. In older Chester County neighborhoods, rebuilding a stone farmhouse or a 1920s twin with comparable materials can cost more than the house would sell for. In other markets, land value makes the sale price far higher than the rebuild cost. Your insurance follows construction, not Zillow.
In short: the dwelling limit is the biggest lever on price — and the one to get right, not low.
Does Where You Live in Pennsylvania Change the Cost?
The short answer: Yes — Philadelphia and its inner suburbs generally price above the statewide average, while much of rural and central Pennsylvania prices below it.
Pennsylvania's below-national average is a statewide blend that hides real variation. Location shapes premiums through local construction and labor costs, fire protection (distance to a hydrant and station), claim frequency, and weather exposure. Published 2026 studies consistently show Philadelphia at the high end of the state and smaller central-Pennsylvania cities toward the low end, with the collar counties in between.
Within a region, the house matters more than the ZIP. A newer, well-maintained home with a recent roof in an area with good fire protection can price well below a neighbor's older home with original systems. And local risks that aren't in the average — basements prone to water, homes near creeks, properties over old mines — change the coverage you need as much as the price you pay. Our Phoenixville insurance guide shows what that looks like for one borough.
Two Chester County homeowners read that Pennsylvania's average is $1,120. One owns a 2012 colonial with a four-year-old roof, a monitored alarm and a bundled auto policy. The other owns a 1910 stone twin with its original slate roof, older wiring and no bundle.
The practical takeaway: before comparing your premium with any average, compare your house with the one the average describes. Rebuild cost, roof age and the systems behind the walls explain most of the distance between a published figure and a real quote.
In short: location sets a regional baseline; your specific house moves you around it.
What About Flood and Mine Subsidence Coverage?
The short answer: Neither is included in a standard homeowners policy or in its published averages — flood requires a separate policy, and mine subsidence coverage costs about 27 cents per $1,000 through the state program.
Two Pennsylvania risks live entirely outside the homeowners premium, and both belong in an honest cost conversation.
| Coverage | In a homeowners policy? | Where it comes from |
|---|---|---|
| Flood | No — excluded | NFIP or a private flood policy; priced on flood risk |
| Mine subsidence | No — excluded | PA DEP program; about 27¢ per $1,000 of coverage |
| Sewer and drain backup | Only by endorsement | Added to the homeowners policy |
| Ordinance or law (code upgrades) | Limited unless increased | Added to the homeowners policy |
Mine subsidence coverage is one of the best values in Pennsylvania insurance. The state program, run by the Department of Environmental Protection, prices at roughly 27 cents per $1,000 of coverage — about $44 a year on a $160,000 policy, per DEP — and DEP offers a free online map to check whether a property sits over a mined area. Flood insurance varies far more, depending on the property's risk; our Pennsylvania home insurance guide covers both gaps and the water backup endorsement that closes the most common one.
In short: the average covers the homeowners policy — budget separately for the Pennsylvania risks it excludes.
How Do You Lower Your Premium Without Losing Protection?
The short answer: Verify the rebuild estimate, choose a deductible you could genuinely pay, claim every discount, bundle with auto, and document updates to the roof and systems.
The levers that lower a Pennsylvania homeowners premium without creating a gap, in the order we work them:
Get the rebuild estimate right. An accurate replacement-cost estimate is the foundation. Too high and you're overpaying; too low and you're exposed.
Choose the deductible deliberately. Moving from $1,000 to $2,500 is often meaningful savings, if the higher amount fits comfortably in your emergency fund. Do the arithmetic on any percentage wind/hail deductible too.
Claim what you qualify for. Protective devices, a newer roof, updated electrical and plumbing, claim-free history and paid-in-full options. And bundling home and auto is usually the largest single credit available.
Keep the coverage that matters. What we steer people away from is dropping water backup, lowering liability or underinsuring the dwelling to hit a number. Those cuts lower the bill by removing exactly the protection Pennsylvania homeowners are most likely to need.
In short: the premium has honest levers — pull those before touching the coverage.
For every credit worth asking about, see our complete guide to Pennsylvania home insurance discounts.
The Bottom Line: The Honest Answer Has Three Layers
The short answer: $1,120 a year is the documented statewide floor (2022 data), roughly $1,200 to $2,200 is where 2026 profile studies land, and a quote on your actual rebuild cost is the only figure that's yours.
So — how much is homeowners insurance in Pennsylvania? The floor: $1,120 a year, the NAIC's average HO-3 premium, well below the national $1,569. The present: roughly $1,200 to $2,200 for a standard home in 2026 studies, after three years of approved increases. The answer: your quote, built on your home's real rebuild cost, roof, location and the deductible and coverage decisions you make on purpose.
Anyone who gives you exactly one number is either quoting a source without saying so or pricing a house that isn't yours.
That quote is what we do. The Brandon Petroziello Agency prices Pennsylvania homes from 21 Gay St in Phoenixville — replacement-cost estimate, deductible options and discounts explained before anything is signed. Call or text (610) 935-9458, or start with the form below. As of September 2026, figures above reflect NAIC homeowners data as tabulated by the Insurance Information Institute, S&P Global Market Intelligence filing analyses and PA DEP program pricing — attributed market data, not quotes, re-verified quarterly.
Related Questions
About this guide. Written and reviewed by the Brandon Petroziello Agency team — licensed Pennsylvania insurance professionals serving Phoenixville and the five-county Philadelphia region (Chester, Montgomery, Delaware, Bucks and Philadelphia), and licensed in Pennsylvania, New Jersey, Delaware and Maryland. Premium averages reference NAIC homeowners data (2022 data year) as tabulated by the Insurance Information Institute; approved rate changes reference S&P Global Market Intelligence analyses of Pennsylvania filings as publicly reported; mine subsidence pricing references the PA Department of Environmental Protection; profile-study ranges summarize publicly published 2026 estimates. All figures are market context and attributed averages, not quotes. PA License #3002942806.
Last reviewed by the Brandon Petroziello Agency team on September 22, 2026.